Smart Shopping
The Black Friday Illusion: How “Sales” Are Engineered, and How to Spot a Fake Deal
That big red “50% OFF” sticker might not be the bargain it looks like. Here’s how holiday pricing tricks work, what to watch for, and how a free price-tracking tool like Keepa can show you whether a deal is real.
Every November the countdown timers start, the inbox fills up, and every retailer suddenly has a “once-a-year” price. Black Friday, Cyber Monday, Boxing Day and the “12 Days of Deals” are built to make you feel like you’ll lose out if you wait.
Some of those deals are real. A lot of them aren’t, and the difference is usually hidden in the product’s price history, which most shoppers never look at.
Black Friday “deals” checked by UK consumer group Which? were the same price or cheaper at some other point in the year. They’ve found much the same result every year they’ve run the study.
The Oldest Trick: Raise the Price, Then “Cut” It
The most common tactic is simple. A seller raises a product’s price weeks or months before the holidays. That higher price becomes the “regular” or “was” price. When Black Friday comes, the price drops back to about where it was in the summer, and now it carries a big discount badge.
On paper it says “Was $199, now $129, save 35%!” In reality, the product may have sold for $129, or less, for most of the year.
In Canada, this isn’t just shady, it can be illegal. The Competition Bureau says advertising a made-up “regular price” to create a fake discount breaks the Competition Act. In November 2025, ahead of Black Friday, the Bureau warned that complaints about inflated regular prices were surging. Fake “regular prices” still show up, especially from online marketplace sellers who are hard to hold accountable.
Other Holiday Sales Tactics to Watch For
- Fake countdown timers and “today only” claims
The timer runs out and the same price is back tomorrow, or it stays all week. Urgency makes you skip the research, and that’s the point.
- “Almost sold out” pressure
Low-stock warnings and “12 people are viewing this” pop-ups can be exaggerated or simply made up. Real scarcity is rare on mass-produced items.
- Special “Black Friday models”
Some TVs, laptops and appliances are made just for the sales season with cheaper parts, fewer ports or weaker specs. The model number is slightly different, so you can’t compare it directly to the “real” version.
- Inflated “compare at” or “MSRP” prices
A discount measured against a list price nobody actually charges is meaningless. What matters is what the item really sold for recently.
- Bundles that hide the math
“Free” accessories or “buy 2, save 20%” deals can make it hard to tell whether you’re actually saving money, or just buying things you didn’t need.
- Early “Black Friday” sales in October
Spreading the event over a month or more makes it harder to track prices and keeps you shopping longer.
- Prices that drop again in January
For many products, Boxing Day or post-holiday clearance matches or beats the Black Friday price.
How Price Trackers Like Keepa Expose Fake Deals
A price tracker records a product’s price over time, so you can see what it has actually sold for instead of trusting the “was” price on the label. Keepa is one of the most popular trackers for Amazon, and it supports Amazon.ca.
What Keepa does
- Price history charts right on Amazon product pages, going back months or years, covering billions of products.
- Price drop alerts: set the price you’re willing to pay and get notified by email, push notification or other channels when it hits that price.
- Back-in-stock alerts for items that keep selling out.
- Amazon vs. third-party seller prices shown separately, so you can see who’s really offering the deal.
- Free browser extension for Chrome, Firefox, Edge and Safari. No account needed for the basic charts.
How to check a deal in 60 seconds
- Install the Keepa extension in your browser (or go to keepa.com and paste in an Amazon link).
- Open the product page on Amazon.ca and scroll down to the Keepa price chart.
- Set the range to 3 months, then 1 year. Look for a price “bump” in the weeks before the sale. That’s the classic inflate-then-discount pattern.
- Compare the sale price to the lowest price in the last 6–12 months. If it’s the same or higher, it’s not a special deal, it’s a normal price with a sticker on it.
- No rush? Set a price alert at the price you’d be happy with, and let Keepa watch it for you.
Not shopping on Amazon?
Keepa only covers Amazon. For other stores, try CamelCamelCamel (also Amazon-focused, with simple email alerts), the price history and price-drop tracking in Google Shopping, and Canadian deal communities like RedFlagDeals, where shoppers regularly call out fake discounts. Plenty of retailers also offer price matching or price adjustments if the price drops after you buy, so it’s worth asking.
How to Read the Chart: Good Deal vs. Fake Deal
| What the history shows | What it means |
|---|---|
| Price jumped up 4–10 weeks before the sale, then “dropped” | Inflated discount. Probably not a real saving. |
| Sale price matches the price from most of the year | Ordinary price. Buy if you need it, but don’t rush. |
| Sale price is higher than the summer or spring low | Worse than normal. Set an alert and wait. |
| Sale price is a clear all-time or 12-month low | Genuine deal. Good time to buy. |
| Steady price, then a sharp, short drop | Likely real. These tend to go fast. |
Watch out for scam “deal” sites
Holiday season is also peak season for fake online stores, copycat websites and phishing emails offering prices that are too good to be true. Check the web address carefully, avoid paying by wire transfer or gift card, and be wary of links in unexpected emails or texts. If a deal on a big-ticket item is wildly below every other store, it’s probably a scam.
Your Holiday Shopping Checklist
- Make a list of what you actually need before the sales start.
- Start tracking prices on those items now, so you have a baseline to compare against.
- Ignore the “was” price. Compare against the lowest recent price instead.
- Check the exact model number to spot stripped-down “doorbuster” versions.
- Treat countdown timers and stock warnings as marketing, not facts.
- Read the return policy and price-adjustment terms before you buy.
- Remember: if you miss the “deal,” a similar price often comes back in January.
The bottom line: a real bargain is one that beats the product’s actual price history, not its sticker. A couple of minutes with a free tool like Keepa can save you real money and spare you that “I could have got it cheaper in July” feeling.
Buying a new computer, laptop or tech gear this season and not sure it’s the right fit (or the right price)? The Razenet team in Red Deer is happy to help you pick the right equipment, then set it up properly when it arrives.
- Which? annual Black Friday price analyses (which.co.uk)
- Competition Bureau Canada, “Ordinary selling price” and “Businesses: Make sure your Black Friday ‘deals’ are real” (November 2025)
- Keepa browser extension listings and keepa.com
